House Press Secretary Ari Fleischer
White House Briefing Room
Washington, D. C.
September 18, 2001
2:12 P.M. EDT
MR. FLEISCHER: The President made three phone calls today I want to fill you
in on, and then I'll give you a walk-through on the President's schedule. He
spoke with United Nations -- Kofi Annan, the Secretary General of the United
Nations, Kofi Annan, this morning. The Secretary General condemned the terrorist
attacks of September 11th unequivocally, expressed his condolences to the American
The President and the Secretary General agreed that the attacks were against
all freedom-loving people and that all nations should join in the fight against
terrorism. The Secretary General also expressed appreciation to the President
for his message of tolerance which the President conveyed yesterday at Washington's
Islamic Cultural Center.
The President also spoke with President Cardoso of Brazil this morning. President
Cardoso expressed his condolences and solidarity and said that this has been
an attack against Western civilization, against all of humanity.
The President thanked President Cardoso for his statements on behalf of the
American people, and he said that we are facing a different kind of war that
will require patience and cooperation.
And, finally, the President spoke again today with Prime Minister Chretien of
Canada. The President expressed heartfelt appreciation for Canada's solidarity
with the United States and for everything that Canada has done to assist.
Let me just recap the President's day and fill you in a little bit about what
he's going to do this afternoon. In addition to the phone calls to world leaders,
the President convened a meeting of his National Security Council to continue
The President met earlier today, as you know, with a group of charitable organizations
that are doing everything they can to make it easier for the American people's
outpouring of generosity to be easily met. They have set up a special web site,
LIBERTYUNITES.ORG, and the President urges all Americans who want to help to
give to the charity of their choice, or to log on. It will contain information
where they can go to volunteer, to help, as well as to give financially, if
any individual Americans seek to do so.
On the personnel front, the President has a meeting today with his personnel
team. These are part of the regular routine meetings of the White House. The
President will have another one today as he continues to focus on the personnel
appointments to the government.
He will have a meeting later this afternoon with his economic team to discuss
other types of action that may or may not be required to help the economy. And
then this evening he will meet with and have dinner with President Chirac of
One update on the schedule: General Ashcroft -- Attorney General Ashcroft will
brief at 2:30 p.m. The head of FEMA will brief at 3:00 p.m. And Treasury Secretary
O'Neill will brief at 4:00 p.m., as we continue to fill the American people
in on all events that are going on.
I'm sorry? That will be a closed meeting.
Let me give you an update, too, on some of the activities around the administration,
and then I'll be happy to take questions. Secretary Paige will be holding an
interactive satellite town meeting from the Newseum to discuss talking with
children about last week's disasters, as well as parental involvement in their
At the Environmental Protection Agency, Administrator Whitman announced today
that results from the Agency's air and drinking water monitored near the World
Trade Center and the Pentagon disaster sites indicate that vital resources are
safe. The Administrator also announced that EPA has been given up to $83 million
from FEMA to support EPA's involvement in the clean-up activities and ongoing
monitoring of environmental conditions in New York City and the Washington,
At the Small Business Administration, the Administrator is in New York City
today to talk about SBA's plans to assist those in need through its disaster
loan program. The SBA offers low-interest long-term financial assistance to
help victims with their disaster-related losses.
Two more agencies, and then I'll be pleased for questions. At Treasury the IRS
released new information to help the people use charitable organizations and
announced it will speed processing of requests for tax-exempt status from the
new charities formed to assist the victims of the attacks. And the IRS is also
compiling a publication called, "Disaster Relief: Providing Assistance
Through Charitable Organizations," which will explain how to make contributions
through existing charitable organizations and how new organizations can apply
for tax-exempt status.
And finally, as you know, the Secretary of Transportation met with airline executives
to discuss the safety, the security and the stabilization of the American airline
And with that, I'm happy to take your questions.
QUESTION: Ari, on the airline industry, is the administration moving toward
the $24 billion figure that the airline is talking about? And on another point,
are you confident that the current financial woes of the airline industry are
wholly owing to last week's attacks? They've been having a bad year up until
now. I'm just wondering if there's any concern by the administration that you
may be picking up the tab for what had been a bad year up until last Tuesday?
MR. FLEISCHER: The Secretary of Transportation, as well as senior White House
officials, met with executives of the airline industry today. This was after
their meeting with the President -- after the staff and the Secretary met with
the President yesterday.
His charge to them was to come up with the specifics of a plan to help the airlines
deal with the consequences of the attack on the United States and its implications
for the airlines. That was the President's charge. And the plan that Secretary
Mineta alluded to earlier that he is working on and will consult with the Congress
on deals with helping the airlines so they can be secure, so they can be safe
and they can be stable in the wake of this attack.
QUESTION: But Ari, on the two questions about the $24 billion, and are you confident
that you're not picking up the tab for the first nine months of this year as
well as what's happened since --
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, I thought I addressed that second question when I said
the President's charge was to do so in the wake of the attack. On the first
question, it's premature to know what the exact dollar amount will be. Clearly,
the airlines have a dollar amount in mind, and that will be something that the
government -- the administration, working with the Congress, considers.
QUESTION: Ari, on the economy, the President and Congress are now discussing,
we understand, seven or eight different options, some of which I gather include
another tax cut to stimulate the economy. And I know the President is interested
in having the administration consult with Congress and it's sort of in that
today. But where is his head, at this time, about what would best stimulate
the economy now? He certainly knows about this, he's thought about it, he's
thought about his first tax cut. So where's his head now? Capital gains? Is
that a good idea?
MR. FLEISCHER: The President is actually -- I've heard him say, these are no
ordinary times. And he said, this is an economy that's going to get a dose of
both supply side and Keynesian economics, meaning the advantages of tax cuts
that stimulate the economy, and of course Congress just approved $40 billion
in spending as an immediate -- which has an immediate impact as the money is
spent. That's not $40 billion over a long period of time, that's $40 billion
over a relatively short time, but also which is to address some of the human
suffering that has taken place.
So the President recognizes that this is not an era of normal economics, normal
responses, and he is going to continue to be very open-minded as he works with
the Congress and with Democrats and Republicans about what comes next. But it's
premature to know exactly what comes next.
Yesterday's meeting that the President led about the economy and the airlines
is the first of many meetings he's going to hold. I just indicated there is
another one this afternoon. And so this is the beginning of a process where
the President is going to consider what exact actions.
QUESTION: But is he more than open-minded, is he actually committed to further
tax relief? Does he believe that's what the economy needs right now?
MR. FLEISCHER: Premature. It's premature to say. He'll have another meeting
this afternoon and he'll listen to various thoughts from various advisers. But
he has not come to any determinations yet.
QUESTION: What's first on the agenda tonight for Chirac? Discussions?
MR. FLEISCHER: I haven't seen the agenda specifically for the meeting, but I
anticipate it's going to be about, obviously, the reaction to the terrorist
attack on the United States, ways of cooperating to combat terrorism. I don't
rule out other important bilateral issues will be discussed; anytime two heads
of state are together, that can happen. So that's a summary of the agenda.
QUESTION: Specifically, what did the President want from Chirac?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, again, I think it gets back into the same list of specificity
that I'm not going to go into if you're asking in the context of the attack,
but it's going to be ways to combat terrorism and ways the Western world can
QUESTION: Ari, Britain has said that it, too, wants to aid its airline industry
which is suffering, and said other countries may want to help their national
carriers. Is this opening the door to a lot of economically distorting government
subsidies for the industry, and could it be harmful in the long run if we provide
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, clearly, if it's harmful in the long run, the President
won't opt for it. But what the President does recognize is that this attack
has had consequences, not only on the lives lost, people missing and on the
psyche of our country, but on American commerce, on American industry, on Americans'
ability to travel, one of the most specific examples. And he is not going to
adhere to any one rigid ideology in the wake of this. He's going to explore
what the government needs to do with an open mind to deal with this.
These are not ordinary times. Now, having said that, he's also cognizant of
the fact -- and John Roberts pointed up -- that there are existing economic
conditions that predated this attack on the United States. And he's tasked his
policy makers to consider those factors in determining what the best next steps
QUESTION: Following that idea of the disruption of ordinary life and so forth,
what does the President expect of the American public as he conducts this war
against terrorism? What kind of sacrifices, efforts, work does he want nonmilitary
Americans to do?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, I think, number one, the President is very heartened by
the resolve of the American people. This patriotic rally is in the finest traditions
of our nation. And it's one reason that, as the President said, any act -- anytime
anybody attacks America, it's an act of self-destruction, and that's because
of the strength of our people.
Two, he's asked for patience. Three, he's asked the American people to go back
to work. The President thinks it's very important that people resume their lives.
Every time somebody shows back up at their office, every time somebody is able
to enjoy entertainment once more, every time people travel, it strengthens our
economy, it strengthens our country and makes it easier for the government to
do what needs to be done to fight terrorism.
So those are -- it's a short list of what the President is asking for.
QUESTION: You mentioned the Secretary General had expressed appreciation for
the President's comments yesterday at the Islamic Center. Have you been able
to gauge any other impact that that appearance and those words might have had
across the world?
MR. FLEISCHER: The only way to gauge it is just to hope that acts of violence
don't exist. And the President continues to remind leaders of their job around
this country in calling out to people and urging that no acts of violence exist.
QUESTION: I'm talking about internationally. Has he heard from any Arab country
or Muslim country leaders about this?
MR. FLEISCHER: You may want to check with State. I've got the read on the three
calls the President made today, but I would not be surprised, but State would
have a better read.
QUESTION: On the scope of this response to these attacks, while the immediate
focus is on these perpetrators, all administration officials have said is it's
to eliminate the scourge of terrorism around the world. There's terrorism in
Ireland, Colombia, the Philippines, Russia. Is that what the administration
MR. FLEISCHER: The President has made it clear that this will be broad and this
will be sweeping, and that anybody who is part of the worldwide network that
exists to foster terrorism anywhere will be included in this. Make no mistake:
That is the charge that the President has set.
QUESTION: Does he believe it's all linked to one network?
MR. FLEISCHER: Wherever it is. That will be the actions the President takes.
QUESTION: Ari, did he ask Kofi Annan to do anything? Have you heard from the
Taliban? Have you heard from Pakistan?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, first of all, the United Nations has already done something.
The United Nations Security Council passed a resolution on September 12th condemning
QUESTION: Does he want anything concrete?
MR. FLEISCHER: Beyond that, there's nothing to report today. If there is any
additional with the United Nations, I'll keep you informed. There's nothing
beyond that from today with the U.N.
QUESTION: How about Pakistan and the Taliban? What do you hear?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, as you know, we are not indicating with specificity what
actions we have asked Pakistan to take. Nevertheless, the status of our reaction
to what Pakistan has done remains unchanged. In other words, the President continues
to be very satisfied with the steps that Pakistan has taken to help the United
States at this time.
QUESTION: Ari, in light of what's happened --
QUESTION: And what do you hear from Afghanistan?
MR. FLEISCHER: Afghanistan, at least the ruling Taliban, have been all over
the lot. They've been giving a series of messages to the United States government,
one seemingly contradictory from the other. So the message to Afghanistan remains
loud and remains clear: Those nations who harbor terrorists will not be spared.
QUESTION: Ari, a couple things. Yesterday I asked if the President had specifically
decided whether or not to seek U.N. Security Council endorsement for any military
act that would fall under the umbrella of this crusade against -- war against
terrorism. Do you have an answer to that?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, there's no specificity yet on whether or not anything else
will be asked of the United Nations. But, of course, in accordance with the
United Nations Charter, all nations have the right to act in self-defense. But
whether or not there will be any additional requests made to the U.N., I can't
give you an indication yet, Major.
QUESTION: Okay. Back on the airline legislation, the industry has been giving
the Hill for several days now a very specific list of things it would like to
see done. You have now talked, and the Transportation Secretary talked about
coming up with your own plan. Does that suggest that what the air industry has
put before Congress does not meet with entire administration approval, and you
want to go in a different direction?
MR. FLEISCHER: No, I think what it suggests is that even at this time, the administration,
the Congress are going to exercise their discretion and their judgment. They
will of course work with affected constituencies. But in all times, war and
peace, constituencies come to the United States government with requests, and
those requests get considered. That doesn't mean they get considered and everyone
of them approved just exactly as proposed. That's how our government works,
in all times.
QUESTION: Ari, National Airport -- Reagan National Airport is a vital transportation
center. It is also the main airport of the capital of the United States. It's
a symbol. The President wants the United States to get back to normality as
quickly as possible. I know there are security problems, and they're trying
to be addressed. Does the President have any sense or any feeling that he would
like Reagan National open, or is he willing to wait?
MR. FLEISCHER: That will be a decision that's made by the appropriate security
authorities and by the Department of Transportation. That's not going to be
a decision made by the President. The President is of course aware of the inconvenience
that this has caused to people in the Washington D.C. area. He wishes there
were no inconveniences to travelers or to residents anywhere in the United States.
But it's a recognition of what happens when you have an airport so extraordinarily
close to so many major governmental and important facilities.
QUESTION: Not just inconvenience to travelers, it happens to be one of the most
vital industries of the capital and the metropolitan area, the state of Virginia.
MR. FLEISCHER: Sure, it is. And again, many economies, many industries have
been affected by this. But as the government reacts to all of this, security
will always be an important concern. And I think that people recognize that.
QUESTION: Ari, what about the Middle East and the President's reaction to talk
of a cease-fire, and will he address this, do you think, in his meeting with
Chirac for the cameras?
MR. FLEISCHER: I think there is an open event with
Chirac -- is it a pool event? Pool at the top on Chirac.
QUESTION: I just wondered if he had a specific intention to address it -- I
mean, I know he'll take questions.
MR. FLEISCHER: I have not seen his remarks for tonight with Chirac yet, so --
QUESTION: But, nevertheless, his reaction -- can you tell us his reaction?
MR. FLEISCHER: His reaction to --
QUESTION: To talk of cease-fire now in the Middle East?
MR. FLEISCHER: Oh, yes. Thank you. The President welcomes the positive statements
by Chairman Arafat, including a call for a complete cease-fire for the exercise
of maximum self-restraint and for a resumption of direct contacts between the
The President hopes to see these steps implemented immediately on the ground.
The President also welcomes the Israeli government statement that it has called
a halt to its offensive military operations.
The President has called on all parties, and he reiterates it today, to seize
this moment and do everything possible in the wake of this attack on the United
States, to move forward with the peace process in the Middle East. So, the President
welcomes today's remarks.
David, go ahead.
QUESTION: Let me just --
QUESTION: There's a guy in the back that has had his hand up for 20 minutes.
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, Mr. Kinsolving, when you're the press secretary, you will
be able to call on anybody in any order.
QUESTION: No, no, I'm just suggesting, because he's had his hand up for 20 minutes,
MR. FLEISCHER: As far as I can tell, everybody in this room has had their hand
up since I got here.
QUESTION: Does the President have some indication now whether Israel will be
a willing partner or a hindrance to this coalition that's being assembled?
MR. FLEISCHER: Well, the President hopes that all nations around the world will
help to resolve this matter. And he's going to have continued conversations
with Israel and with the government of Israel. But it's also important for Israel
and for the Palestinian Authority to do all they can to seize this opportunity
to move forward on peace in the Middle East which will, in and of itself, be
a major contribution to reducing terrorism and violence around the world.
QUESTION: Ari, I just want to make it clear when we asked before about the President's
statements about eradicating terrorism around the world, how -- and not being
specific to Osama bin Laden and his organization -- how do we then work with
Iran, which there's been talk of doing in spite of the fact that they harbor
terrorists and fund Hezbollah? I mean, do we make their cooperation contingent
upon serving Hezbollah to us?
MR. FLEISCHER: I think it's going to be a very complicated matter. With different
states it's going to be more complicated. And I think the basic approach that
we can look at is -- as I indicated yesterday, some nations are going to be
able to do more, some nations are going to be able to do an awful lot. Other
nations may be only able to do a little. But if that little is constructive,
that little will proceed.
The approach of the government will involve both a carrot and a stick. And in
different nations, the carrot may be bigger, in other nations the stick may
QUESTION: Ari, isn't it likely that in order to get Iran's cooperation, we would
have to essentially give them implicit, if not explicit, promise that we're
not going to go after their own operations?
MR. FLEISCHER: I think it all depends on what the definition of cooperation
is by various nations around the world. And that's why I indicated it's a complicated
measure. There will be different actions taken with different governments. And
I'm not going to say specifically what it would be with Iran, but --
QUESTION: I don't think it's been over 19 minutes, actually. (Laughter.)
MR. FLEISCHER: Very effective way to get a question to the back.