Middle East in Photo Op
New York Governor George Pataki
New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg
The Oval Office
The White House
April 1, 2002
11:15 A.M. EST
THE PRESIDENT: I have just informed the Governor and the Mayor, the Governor
of New York and the Mayor of New York City, that the federal government will
transfer Governor's Island to the people of New York. I'll never forget choppering
over Governor's Island with George and Rudy Giuliani, Mike Bloomberg's predecessor,
and the two leaders talking about what good use Governor's Island could be put
Since that time, I've studied the statements of Mayor Bloomberg, who extensively
talked about Governor's Island and how to improve Governor's Island and how
to make it a center of educational excellence, something dear to George Pataki's
heart. I looked at the law, looked at the circumstances and decided this morning
that this was the right thing for the U.S. government and it's the right thing
for the people of New York.
I appreciate so very much the vision of these two leaders and I appreciate their
heartfelt concern for the citizens of New York City and the region. And so I
want to welcome to the Oval Office with this piece of news. George, why don't
you say a few words?
GOVERNOR PATAKI: Mr. President, first, on behalf of the people of New York,
thank you. This is great news for New York. For decades, New Yorkers have sought
to have control over Governor's Island so we could use it in an intelligent
way to advance the interest of New Yorkers. And now you are doing it.
And I remember very well that flight in the helicopter and that very sad and
emotional day, and how you took the interest in Governor's Island. And, Mr.
President, we have said to you that we're going to bring back Lower Manhattan
stronger than it was on September 11th, with the resources you've provided,
with having kept your word on what you're going to do for New York, and now
going beyond that to transfer Governor's Island to the people of New York. I'll
tell you, it's just a tremendous thing.
Mike and I had the chance Friday afternoon to go over and tour Governor's Island.
And we have a vision as to a bold educational use for that island that will
be tremendous for the people of New York, for the school children of New York.
And, Mr. President, again, thank you. You have done more for New York than I
believe any President in memory.
THE PRESIDENT: Thank you. Mike?
MAYOR BLOOMBERG: Mr. President, thank you so much for this. I think not only
is it a commitment to New York, but it is a commitment to education. You have
the right to claim to be the education President as much as anybody in modern
memory. I think the Governor has been phenomenally supportive of education throughout
New York State and been very helpful in New York City. It is my big concern.
We need more trained teachers and we need more classrooms. We need to improve
our university system. This will allow us to do all three by putting part of
City University, one of the flagships of New York, over on Governor's Island.
That will free up space so that we can solve some of our space problems throughout
the public school system, where we have just too big class sizes for the children's
The Governor has for a long time tried to do something to reduce class sizes.
We've never had the space before. This will go to ameliorate that problem to
a great extent. It will let us focus on teacher training. It will let us focus
on smaller class sizes. It will improve our City University and the public school
system where we educate America's future.
So on behalf of the governor and I, thank you. You could not make a bigger impact,
I don't think, on America going forward than you can by this gesture. And we
will use it wisely.
THE PRESIDENT: I know you will. Thanks.
I'll be glad to answer a few questions.
QUESTION: Mr. President, what specifically would you like for Chairman Arafat
to do, what specific action you'd like him to take in the Middle East? And,
in light of the current situation in Israel, does the Bush doctrine on terrorism
not apply in this case?
THE PRESIDENT: Well, first of all, there will never be peace so long as there's
terror. And all of us must fight off -- fight terror. And you asked about Chairman
Arafat. I'd like to see Chairman Arafat denounce the terrorist activities that
are taking place, the constant attacks.
We've got a plan that will lead to peace, the security plan called Tenet, there's
a political plan called Mitchell. Both sides have agreed to this plan. And we
urge the parties to accept the Tenet plan so that we can bring some -- a peaceful
resolution to an issue that's affecting the lives of Palestinians and Israelis
alike. There's a lot of innocent people who hurt in the region because of the
senseless violence and senseless murder.
QUESTION: Mr. President, I'd like to follow up on Sonya's question. Under your
doctrine, a terrorist or someone who aids a terrorist is the equivalent of a
terrorist. So what's keeping Chairman Arafat -- what's keeping you from labeling
Chairman Arafat a terrorist?
THE PRESIDENT: Chairman Arafat has agreed to a peace process. He's agreed to
the Tenet plan. He's agreed to the Mitchell plan. He has negotiated with parties
as to how to achieve peace. And, of course, our hope is that he accepts the
Tenet plan. That's what General Zinni is in the Middle East doing, working to
get this Tenet agreement in place, which is a series of concrete steps to reduce
the violence in the Middle East.
QUESTION: There were various calls on the Sunday talk shows for you to become
more actively involved in this process, sir. Is there any way you would do that?
THE PRESIDENT: You know, they must have not been with me in Crawford when I
was on the phone all morning long talking to world leaders. We've just come
from a National Security Council meeting where Colin Powell was recounting his
phone conversations. We've got General Zinni in the region. We've got a Tenet
plan, a Mitchell plan, a road map to what will be a peaceful resolution to this
I hope that the world community will continue to condemn terror. And if they
haven't condemned terror yet, start condemning terror. It's essential for the
peace of the region and the world that we rout out terrorist activities, that
we condemn those activities. Suicide bombers in the name of religion is simple
terror. And the free world, the civilized world must band together to stop this
kind of activity if we expect there to be peace and resolution in the Middle
QUESTION: You've made clear, sir, that you believe that Chairman Arafat needs
to do much more. Do you believe that Prime Minister Sharon is doing all he can
to foster peace in the region?
THE PRESIDENT: I think it's very important for the Prime Minister to keep a
pathway to peace open, to understand that on the one hand, Israel should protect
herself, and on the other hand, there ought to be a pathway, the capacity to
achieve a peaceful resolution to this issue. It's important for Israel to understand
that. They've signed on to the Tenet agreement, and they signed on to the Mitchell
plan. And that is the pathway to peace. And I believe Prime Minister Sharon
still accepts Tenet, and still accepts Mitchell as the way to achieve a peaceful
I was very heartened a couple of weeks ago by the Saudi Arabia Crown Prince,
when he talked about the need for the Arab world to recognize Israel's right
to exist. It was a positive development. There were some positive things that
were taking place in the region, until the terrorist suicide bombers start killing
QUESTION: Mr. President, why give the island now? Can you tell us what --
THE PRESIDENT: Why now, right this second?
QUESTION: Well, why did you make the announcement today, and what persuaded
you to transfer the island to the city? And also, was this in any way to help
Governor Pataki in his reelection?
THE PRESIDENT: Well, listen, he doesn't need my help to get re-elected, for
starters. He's got a great record. The people of New York are discerning voters.
Well, most of the time they're discerning voters. (Laughter.) If you know what
I mean. (Laughter.)
QUESTION: No, what do you mean? (Laughter.)
THE PRESIDENT: Well, you're a smart guy. Read between the lines. No, George
Pataki has been a great Governor for New York. I made the announcement today,
because I had finished the necessary study of the issue, to make sure that we
could transfer this property without congressional action. And I believe I can
do that. It took a while to take a look at it.
It also requires -- I wanted to make sure that the Governor and Mayor would
be using this property for education purposes. That's what the Mayor said he
would do, the Governor said he wanted to do that. They took a look at it and
decided this is what they wanted to do. And it makes a lot of sense to me. And
using it for education purposes will make it easier for me to facilitate the
transfer, by the way.
QUESTION: Mr. President, the previous administration didn't want -- I was just
wondering, what specifically persuaded you?
THE PRESIDENT: Well, I took a look at it. I mean, it's a good question. I took
a look at it. I listened to what George said; he's my friend. I trust his judgment.
I've known him for a long time, and Rudy Giuliani as well, both of them were
passionate in their appeal for us to consider transferring Governor's Island.
And I knew Mike was very interested in enhancing the quality of education in
New York City. And I took a look at it. I came back -- obviously, things didn't
happen quickly after September the 15th trip, because we had a lot on our mind.
But it took a while to work it through the White House staff.
And it arrived on my desk sometime last week. And the recommendation was that
we could transfer this property, if that's what I wanted to do. And it's something
I want to do, because I think it's going to make the life of a city that has
been tragically affected by killers and murderers better. And I think it will
enhance the quality of education for the people of New York. And to me, that
is a worthwhile and noble cause.